LEWISTON — The Legislature is considering whether to provide an option for Maine’s school superintendents to tack on an hour a day rather than extend the school year to make up for the season’s snow days and other emergency closures.
The bill, LD 129, sponsored by state Rep. William Tuell, R-East Machias, would allow districts to extend up to 25 school days by one hour, calculating five one-hour sessions as equal to one missed school day.
The Education and Cultural Affairs Committee heard the bill on Feb. 25, when it received the full support of the Maine School Management Association, the Maine Principals’Association, Elm Street Elementary School Principal Tony Maker of East Machias and AOS 96 Superintendent Scott K. Porter of Washington County, as more cost-effective and less disruptive than adding school days to the calendar or scheduling Saturday sessions.
One of the bill’s co-sponsors, Rep. Michael McClellan, R-Raymond, said he considers the one-hour option very “Maine-ish.”
“We in Maine pride ourselves on local control, letting local schools decide what is best for their students, and what is in keeping with the community values,” McClellan said.
The Maine Education Association, which represents teachers’ unions, opposes the bill.
In outlining that opposition, MEA President Lois Kilby-Chesley stressed that adding an hour to the school day would create problems for families who use child care providers, and for the providers themselves. She asked lawmakers to consider whether it is “developmentally appropriate to ask a 5-, 6- or 7-year-old to be in school for seven to eight hours.” She also questioned the academic value of a longer school day, the impact it would have on sports scheduling and the difficulties it would present for school staff who have second jobs.
Despite that opposition, the Education Committee on Tuesday voted the measure ought to pass. It will now go to the full Legislature for debate.
If it passes, Spruce Mountain School District Superintendent Kenneth Healey is not sure it will work in his district because students there already have a long day, with some boarding buses at 6:10 a.m. in Jay, Livermore and Livermore Falls.
Healey said he thinks a longer school day would be less manageable than the current system of adding full days, especially in rural districts where the school day is already extended by long bus commutes.
“It really messes with the normal school day and sports and after-school activities schedules,” he said. “Children already get home late enough with our already established schedules.”
Despite these concerns, he said he would bring the option before his board.
Lewiston Superintendent Bill Webster was pleased the bill would make this choice optional for school districts. “I don’t see us doing this in Lewiston, and it would require negotiations with our unions,” he said.
He said the district has used six snow days so far this year, which is one fewer than all of last year. “So, while this year’s storms have made the winter seem particularly severe, from a snow day standpoint it is not that different.”
Auburn Superintendent Katy Grondin said she didn’t oppose the idea of an extended school day. “It’s nice to have the option.”
She added, “We’re not in a crisis. We’re getting out June 18 right now. We’ve been out June 18 before.” If Auburn were looking at continuing school through late June that may be different, Grondin said.
“One thing I like about extending the day is it would be more effective than extra days at the end of the year,” Grondin said. “If the extra hour was an option, I would like that.”
Dr. Thomas Ward, principal of the Mt. Blue School District in Farmington, said in an email that no one has asked him to consider extending the school day. Five days have been missed so far because of the weather.
In Bethel, SAD 44 Superintendent David Murphy said if the legislation is passed, he would consider looking at it, “but there are a lot of scheduling issues to consider. We’ll talk about it and see where we stand once (lawmakers) make a decision.”
SAD 44 students have used one more snow day than scheduled this year, and will have to make up that day.
Sheila Raymond, business manager for the Rangeley Lakes Regional School District, said last week that the district has used only four snow days and the issue of adding time isn’t being discussed.
A representative from RSU 58 in Phillips said the board hasn’t discussed it, and noted that a policy change would have to be implemented before the option could be used.
Comments are no longer available on this story