MINOT — Selectmen on Monday agreed to challenge the Board of Appeals’ decision that would allow developer Chuck Starbird to build a house on his lot located beyond the town-accepted portion of York Road.
Selectmen took this action following a closed door session with Norm Rattey, the town’s attorney. The vote to take the appeals board’s decision before a Superior Court judge was unanimous.
Last Tuesday, Nov. 9, the appeals board reversed its decision of Sept. 15 that denied Starbird his building permit. Town ordinance gave selectmen 15 days to challenge the appeals board action.
“The selectmen are disputing their decision. We have a different opinion,” board Chairman Dean Campbell said.
Selectmen thought the appeals board had it right in September when it backed Code Enforcement Officer Ken Pratt’s decision in June denying Starbird a building permit.
In June, Pratt ruled that Starbird’s property didn’t have the required frontage on a town accepted road. Starbird’s 5.2 acre lot, at its closest point, lies 135 feet beyond the end of York Road.
On Nov. 9 the appeals board, with David Murphy dissenting, accepted Starbird’s lawyer, Scott Lynch’s argument that while the Starbird property had no frontage on the officially accepted portion of York Road, it did have frontage on a public easement that runs from the end of York Road through to Death Valley Road.
Lynch argued that the public easement was Starbird’s right of way to the public road and cited the section of the town’s land use ordinance that states: “back lots may be developed for uses permitted in the district if they can be provided with a right of way that connects with a public street.”
Prior to the selectmen’s executive session with Rattey, Planning Board member John Gould told selectmen that, whatever the interpretation, the Planning Board’s original intent regarding how back lots would be dealt with, was that if you had a lot with just five acres “you had to have frontage on a town road.”
Selectmen did not elaborate on how their reading of the ordinance might differ from the way it was interpreted on Nov. 9.
In other business, selectmen authorized town administrator Arlan Saunders to proceed with an agreement with TRIO, a division of Harris Computer Systems of Bangor, to provide technical assistance for the town’s data system.
Selectmen acknowledged that the switchover from Northern Data Systems will cost the town about $12,000 but figured that lower annual maintenance costs should make up the difference in a few years.
Pushing selectmen toward their decision was what selectmen perceived as deteriorating customer service.
“If we aren’t getting service from our present vendor then we have to move,” Campbell said.
Selectman Eda Tripp, who is responsible for Thanksgiving baskets, told the board that donations this year are down, that nothing had come in from the Girl Scouts or Boy Scouts. She wondered if now that the Minot Consolidated School no longer has its middle school students, nothing would be coming from that source.
“We usually do about 12 baskets. We’re going to have a hard time doing it this year, there’s not a can downstairs,” Tripp said.
Comments are no longer available on this story